Skip to main content

In praise of middle reader books

Have you ever compared a book that your child has read with a book from your own childhood that you read when you were your child's age? Well I have and I can tell you I can better understand the attraction my son's books have for him and the reason for his disdain when I mention the books I read as a child.


As you can see from my bookshelf, I have been reading quite a bit of books my older son is reading. He is 10 and we are reading books for the 9-12 age range.This means I've been through Harry Potter and working my way through Rick Riordon's Lightning Thief series, but I am still behind.

Lucas enjoys fantasy and the books are usually fast-paced, with traces of humour, and although they deal with good vs evil issues, generally the plots are simple and don't make me stay awake at night. I don't need adult thriller fiction to keep me interested, in fact, better not since some adult books are quite gory.

When I was growing up I read a ton of Enid Blyton, and my favourite series was The Secret Seven. So I KEPT MY BOOKS FROM WHEN I WAS 9, so I could bequeath them to my children, starting with Lucas. And I imagined the beatific smile that Lucas would grant me and the glow of gratitude at the wonderful gift I bestowed on him. You can imagine what I got instead.

When I compare the books, the pace of The Secret Seven was very sedate (I might even say slow), very simple plots, not a whole lot of characters. I am surprised by the complexity of children's books now and the amount of characters and interactions children keep in their heads. And, I will dare to say it. My books were simpler. Reflective of another era.
Labels:

Comments

Savi said…
Hi Sally,

Just wanted to say, I agree completely! I've tried reading Enid Blyton books to my kids (The Wishing Chair, The Magic Faraway Tree), and they have no appeal, and I can see why. Today's books are just so much more sophisticated and interesting. Jamie and I just started on The Lightning Thief last night - it seems really good so far. I had been thinking for a while to try and get a copy of Enid Blyton's Tales of Long Ago (now out of print) to introduce the kids to Greek and Roman legends, but this book is so much better!

Take care,
Savi
5 December 2011 at 08:32
Austin Trini said…
Hi Savi -
That is so funny that we have the same outlook on this. I too bought The Wishing Chair for Lucas. I told him a friend of mine was reading The Lightning Thief and that he might meet you some day. He seemed less interested in you and more so in meeting Jamie (that is, another boy his age who is reading those books!)
5 December 2011 at 20:47
Savi said…
I think Jamie would love to meet Lucas - they have a lot in common. And I would love to see you again. Maybe someday we can arrange it. You do know you and yours have a holiday crash pad in Scotland whenever you want to use it (Space would be tight but we would manage!)
7 December 2011 at 13:58
Austin Trini said…
Thanks Savi!
You know I have the most wonderful memories of Scotland so I would love for us to visit :)
8 December 2011 at 16:41
Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Talking with Lucas on climate change

This is my post for Blog Action Day . This is an annual event where bloggers everywhere in the world post about the same issue on the same day to spark discussion around an issue of global importance. This is part of a conversation I had with my 8-year old. Mama : Do you know what climate change means? Lucas : I think it means when it is like 90F and it is hot.   And the change? It's when in the daytime it might be 90F and sunny and hot, and then you go inside for dinner and then right after dinner and it might have dropped to 70F Well, yes it is that in a way.  That describes what is happening in your area, but when people use the term "climate change" they really mean something more global, like affecting climate around the world Have you heard of the team "global warming"? What global warming is that it is made up of CO2 (carbon dioxide) and when they burn stuff the smoke releases CO2 and it's like a blanket covering the earth and if it k...
9 comments
Read more

My little Karateka-in-training...

Lucas recently tested for his high white belt (karate) and as I looked in on him through the glass doors to his class, I was overwhelmed by the sense of my little boy on his own in the world.  He looked so small in his white Gi in front of the table where his Sensei, her Sensei and another instructor, sat.  I watched him stand with his weight on one foot, then the other, doing jumping jacks to warm up and practicing kicks and blocks with his classmates. I felt the tears well up and got that old lump in the throat.  I hadn't felt like that in a long, long time with Lucas, why now? I think that unlike his spelling test, where I can help him by reviewing the words with him, or his Maths,  this was something he had to do on his own. I couldn't help him. Heck, I didn't even know what the right moves were!  I guess he is at the age where he will have more and more independent experiences.  I will hold on to this picture of him in my mind, and the feeling th...
6 comments
Read more

Cancer by the numbers 2 of 4: That grocery bill

This is the second "Cancer by the Numbers" post, the first was about blood counts . We have been trying to eat organic fruits and vegetables as much as we can, to reduce the pesticide levels we injest. I will publish another post about cancer and food, but for now I thought I'd share the cost of organic vs not organic based on a quick poll of my local grocery (HEB).  We had cut out meat prior to my diagnosis of cancer (ever since reading The China Study ) so perhaps the decline in spending in meat is offset by the more pricey organic items! The graph below shows the increase, as a percentage of the non-organic price, that I pay for common items that I buy. While the actual dollar amounts may not be significant individually, I can tell you that I really feel it on my grocery bill when I buy blueberries! If you feel you want to buy organic, but want to spend the dollars on those items where it makes a difference, take a look at the  Environmental Working ...
5 comments
Read more